It is noticed that Pb²⁺ is more stable than Pb⁴⁺ but Sn²⁺ is less stable than Sn⁴⁺. Observe the following reactions.
Q. It is noticed that Pb2+ is more stable than Pb4+ but Sn2+ is less stable than Sn4+. Observe the following reactions.

PbO2 + Pb → 2PbO; ΔrG° (1)

SnO2 + Sn → 2SnO; ΔrG° (2)

Identify the correct set from the following
A. ΔrG° (1) > 0; ΔrG° (2) < 0
B. ΔrG° (1) < 0; ΔrG° (2) > 0
C. ΔrG° (1) < 0; ΔrG° (2) < 0
D. ΔrG° (1) > 0; ΔrG° (2) > 0
Correct Answer: B

Explanation

This question is based on the inert pair effect and the relative stability of oxidation states of Group 14 elements.

For lead (Pb), due to strong inert pair effect, the +2 oxidation state is more stable than the +4 oxidation state.

Reaction (1):

PbO2 contains Pb in +4 oxidation state, while PbO contains Pb in +2 oxidation state.

The reaction converts Pb4+ to Pb2+, which is a more stable oxidation state for lead.

Formation of a more stable oxidation state is thermodynamically favorable.

Therefore,

$$ \Delta_r G^\circ (1) < 0 $$

For tin (Sn), the inert pair effect is much weaker, and the +4 oxidation state is more stable than the +2 oxidation state.

Reaction (2):

SnO2 contains Sn in +4 oxidation state, while SnO contains Sn in +2 oxidation state.

The reaction converts Sn4+ to Sn2+, which is a less stable oxidation state for tin.

Formation of a less stable oxidation state is thermodynamically unfavorable.

Therefore,

$$ \Delta_r G^\circ (2) > 0 $$

Hence, the correct set is:

ΔrG° (1) < 0; ΔrG° (2) > 0

Related JEE Main Chemistry Questions

Updated for JEE Main 2026: This PYQ is important for JEE Mains, JEE Advanced and other competitive exams. Practice more questions from this chapter.

Scroll to Top