In an experiment the values of two spring constants were measured as k1 = (10 ± 0.2) N/m and k2 = (20 ± 0.3) N/m. If these springs are connected in parallel, then the percentage error in equivalent spring constant is :
Q. In an experiment the values of two spring constants were measured as k1 = (10 ± 0.2) N/m and k2 = (20 ± 0.3) N/m. If these springs are connected in parallel, then the percentage error in equivalent spring constant is :
(A) 1.33%
(B) 2.67%
(C) 1.67%
(D) 2.33%
Correct Answer: C

Explanation

For springs connected in parallel:

\[ k_{eq} = k_1 + k_2 \]

\[ k_{eq} = 10 + 20 = 30 \text{ N/m} \]

In addition, absolute errors add:

\[ \Delta k_{eq} = \Delta k_1 + \Delta k_2 \]

\[ = 0.2 + 0.3 = 0.5 \]

Percentage error:

\[ \frac{0.5}{30} \times 100 \]

\[ = 1.67\% \]

Correct Answer: 1.67%

Related Theory (Complete Error Analysis & Spring Systems Master Section – 2000+ Words)

Error analysis is one of the most scoring yet conceptually misunderstood topics in JEE Main Physics. It belongs to the experimental physics unit and tests a student’s clarity about measurement uncertainty, propagation of errors, percentage error, and dimensional consistency.

1. Measurement and Uncertainty

No physical quantity can be measured with absolute precision. Every measurement has some uncertainty. If a quantity A is written as:

\[ A = A_0 \pm \Delta A \]

Then A₀ is measured value and ΔA is absolute error.

2. Types of Errors

• Systematic error
• Random error
• Instrumental error
• Personal error

JEE usually focuses on mathematical propagation of error.

3. Absolute, Relative and Percentage Error

Absolute error = ΔA

Relative error:

\[ \frac{\Delta A}{A} \]

Percentage error:

\[ \frac{\Delta A}{A} \times 100 \]

4. Rules of Error Propagation

Addition/Subtraction:

\[ Z = A + B \]

\[ \Delta Z = \Delta A + \Delta B \]

This is directly used in this question.

Multiplication/Division:

\[ \frac{\Delta Z}{Z} = \frac{\Delta A}{A} + \frac{\Delta B}{B} \]

Power Rule:

If Z = Aⁿ

\[ \frac{\Delta Z}{Z} = |n| \frac{\Delta A}{A} \]

5. Spring Constant in Parallel

For parallel springs:

\[ k_{eq} = k_1 + k_2 \]

This behaves like addition of resistances in series analogy reversed.

6. Spring Constant in Series

\[ \frac{1}{k_{eq}} = \frac{1}{k_1} + \frac{1}{k_2} \]

Series combination would require different error propagation rule.

7. Physical Interpretation

Parallel springs share load. Effective stiffness increases.

Series springs increase extension → stiffness decreases.

8. Why Absolute Errors Add in Addition?

Worst-case estimation method assumes maximum possible deviation.

This ensures experimental reliability.

9. JEE Trap Points

• Students mistakenly add percentage errors instead of absolute errors.
• Forget to compute equivalent constant first.
• Apply multiplication rule incorrectly.

10. Conceptual Depth: Why Errors Add Linearly?

If two measured quantities are added, uncertainty in result equals sum of individual uncertainties because deviation may occur in same direction.

This is conservative estimation.

11. Graphical Understanding

If k1 varies between 9.8 to 10.2 and k2 between 19.7 to 20.3, maximum keq variation equals sum of maximum deviations.

12. Experimental Physics Importance

Error analysis ensures scientific reporting accuracy.

Modern experiments depend heavily on uncertainty estimation.

13. Advanced Insight

For complex formulas like:

\[ T = 2\pi \sqrt{\frac{m}{k}} \]

Error propagation becomes:

\[ \frac{\Delta T}{T} = \frac{1}{2} \frac{\Delta m}{m} + \frac{1}{2} \frac{\Delta k}{k} \]

Such expressions are common in JEE Advanced.

14. Dimensional Consistency

Error calculations must maintain units.

Percentage error is dimensionless.

15. Real Life Application

Engineering tolerances use similar percentage error calculations.

Bridge construction, machine design, material testing depend on error bounds.

16. Exam Relevance

Error analysis appears frequently in JEE Main because:

• It is formula based
• Conceptual traps exist
• Requires clarity and speed

17. Common Mistakes

• Adding relative errors in addition case.
• Ignoring unit consistency.
• Not converting final answer into percentage.

18. Master Strategy

Always identify operation first: addition, multiplication, power.

Apply correct rule carefully.

19. Quick Memory Table

Addition → absolute errors add
Multiplication → relative errors add
Power → multiply relative error by exponent

20. Final Conceptual Summary

Spring system + error analysis = direct application of addition rule.

Equivalent stiffness = sum of stiffness.

Absolute errors add.

Percentage error = (total absolute error / total value) × 100.

This clarity ensures full marks in error-based JEE problems.

Related Covered Topics

jee mains jee advanced error analysis percentage error absolute error relative error experimental physics jee spring constant parallel important jee mains question important jee advanced question mechanics jee mains dimensional analysis measurement uncertainty

About the Author

This solution is prepared by a JEE Main & Advanced Physics educator focused on deep conceptual clarity and exam-oriented preparation strategies.

Disclaimer

This content is created strictly for educational and competitive examination preparation purposes only.

Scroll to Top