Among statements S1 orthocentre third vertex S2 AP concurrent lines

Among statements S1 orthocentre third vertex S2 AP concurrent lines | JEE Main Mathematics
Q MCQ Statements
Among the statements:
STATEMENT S1
If $A(5,-1)$ and $B(-2,3)$ are two vertices of a triangle, whose orthocentre is $(0,0)$, then its third vertex is $(-4,-7)$.
STATEMENT S2
If positive numbers $2a, b, c$ are three consecutive terms of an A.P., then the lines $ax + by + c = 0$ are concurrent at $(2,-2)$.
A) both are incorrect
B) only (S2) is correct
C) both are correct ✓
D) only (S1) is correct
✅ Correct Answer
C) Both are correct
Solution Steps
▶ Verifying S1
1
Set up perpendicularity conditions

Let third vertex be $C(h,k)$. Orthocentre $H(0,0)$.

Condition 1: $AH \perp BC$

$\vec{AH} = (0-5,\;0+1) = (-5,\;1)$

$\vec{BC} = (h+2,\;k-3)$

Dot product $= 0$: $(-5)(h+2) + (1)(k-3) = 0$

$$-5h – 10 + k – 3 = 0 \implies \boxed{5h – k = -13} \quad \cdots(i)$$

2
Second perpendicularity condition

Condition 2: $BH \perp AC$

$\vec{BH} = (0+2,\;0-3) = (2,\;-3)$

$\vec{AC} = (h-5,\;k+1)$

Dot product $= 0$: $2(h-5) + (-3)(k+1) = 0$

$$2h – 10 – 3k – 3 = 0 \implies \boxed{2h – 3k = 13} \quad \cdots(ii)$$

3
Solve simultaneous equations

From (i): $k = 5h + 13$

Substitute into (ii):

$2h – 3(5h + 13) = 13$

$2h – 15h – 39 = 13$

$-13h = 52 \implies h = -4$

$k = 5(-4) + 13 = -7$

∴ Third vertex = $(-4,-7)$ ✓ — S1 is CORRECT

▶ Verifying S2
4
Use AP condition

$2a, b, c$ are in A.P. $\Rightarrow$ common difference is equal:

$b – 2a = c – b \implies 2b = 2a + c$

$$\therefore c = 2b – 2a \quad \cdots(*)$$

5
Substitute into line equation

Line: $ax + by + c = 0$

Replace $c$ using $(*)$:

$ax + by + (2b – 2a) = 0$

$ax – 2a + by + 2b = 0$

$$a(x – 2) + b(y + 2) = 0$$

6
Identify fixed point of concurrence

$a(x-2) + b(y+2) = 0$ holds for ALL values of $a,b$ if and only if:

$$x – 2 = 0 \quad \text{AND} \quad y + 2 = 0$$

$$\implies x = 2,\quad y = -2$$

∴ All lines pass through $(2,-2)$ ✓ — S2 is CORRECT

💡

Key Insight

Both S1 and S2 are correct → Answer C. AP condition always reduces to a(x−2)+b(y+2)=0, a fixed point family.

📚
Theory
1. Orthocentre and Altitude Perpendicularity
The orthocentre $H$ of a triangle is the intersection of its three altitudes. An altitude from vertex $A$ is perpendicular to side $BC$. If $H$ is known, then for any vertex $A$: $\vec{AH} \perp \vec{BC}$, giving $\vec{AH} \cdot \vec{BC} = 0$. Two such conditions from two known vertices yield two equations to find the unknown third vertex.
2. Arithmetic Progression Condition
Three numbers $p, q, r$ are in A.P. iff $q – p = r – q$, i.e., $2q = p + r$. For $2a, b, c$: $2b = 2a + c$, giving $c = 2b – 2a$. This linear relation between $a, b, c$ is the key constraint that determines which point all family lines $ax+by+c=0$ pass through.
3. Family of Lines Through a Fixed Point
The equation $\lambda\,L_1 + \mu\,L_2 = 0$ represents a family of lines passing through the intersection of $L_1=0$ and $L_2=0$, for all values of $\lambda, \mu$. Here $a(x-2) + b(y+2) = 0$ is exactly such a family (with $L_1: x-2=0$, $L_2: y+2=0$), concurrent at $(2,-2)$.
4. Dot Product for Perpendicularity
Two vectors $\mathbf{u} = (u_1, u_2)$ and $\mathbf{v} = (v_1, v_2)$ are perpendicular iff $\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{v} = u_1v_1 + u_2v_2 = 0$. This is equivalent to their slopes satisfying $m_1 m_2 = -1$. In orthocentre problems, always form direction vectors from the known point to unknown vertex, then apply the dot product condition.
5. Verifying Statement-Type Questions
For “Among the statements” JEE problems: verify each statement independently with rigorous calculation. Don’t guess based on patterns. S1 needed two dot product equations and solving 2×2 linear system. S2 needed the AP substitution trick to reveal the fixed point structure. Both verified true independently → answer C.
FAQs
Q
How to find third vertex given orthocentre?
Use AH⊥BC and BH⊥AC. Form dot product = 0 for each. Solve the 2 equations for (h,k).
Q
What is the equation from AH⊥BC?
AH = (-5,1), BC = (h+2,k-3). Dot product: -5(h+2)+(k-3)=0 → 5h-k = -13.
Q
What does 2a,b,c in AP give us?
2b = 2a+c so c = 2b-2a. Substituting: ax+by+(2b-2a) = a(x-2)+b(y+2) = 0.
Q
Why is a(x-2)+b(y+2)=0 concurrent at (2,-2)?
For ANY a,b: substituting x=2,y=-2 gives a(0)+b(0)=0. So (2,-2) lies on every line of this family.
Q
Is the answer C (both correct)?
Yes. S1: third vertex = (-4,-7) verified by perpendicularity. S2: concurrent at (2,-2) verified by AP substitution. Both TRUE → C.
Q
What is the slope method alternative for S1?
slope(AH) = (0-(-1))/(0-5) = -1/5. Altitude AH ⊥ BC → slope(BC) = 5. slope(BH) = (0-3)/(0+2) = -3/2 → slope(AC) = 2/3. Find C as intersection of lines through A,B with these slopes.
Q
How to solve 5h−k=−13 and 2h−3k=13?
From eq(i): k=5h+13. Put in eq(ii): 2h-3(5h+13)=13 → -13h=52 → h=-4. Then k=-7.
Q
What is a family of lines?
A set of lines depending on parameters. λL₁+μL₂=0 all pass through intersection of L₁=L₂=0. Here a(x-2)+b(y+2)=0 passes through (2,-2) for all a,b.
Q
Do we need to verify with third altitude in S1?
No. Two conditions from two vertices uniquely determine C(h,k). The third altitude condition is automatically satisfied (it’s redundant for a valid triangle).
Q
What if 2a,b,c were in GP instead of AP?
In GP: b²=2ac. That’s a non-linear constraint and doesn’t directly give a linear fixed-point. The AP condition is special in giving the linear relation c=2b-2a.
📤 Share with friends!
Scroll to Top